GrayZone – Quarterly Digest – January 2006

Headline News | Artists’ Corner | Busts | Worldwide Update | Legal Beagle | Quick Bits and Bytes

Headline News

i2hub Network Shuts Down Legitimate P2Ps Spring Up

On November 14, 2005, the intercollegiate file-sharing network, i2hub, shut down after the music recording industry threatened to sue it for allowing illegal downloads.

After it was permanently shut down, visitors looking for the network logged on to the i2hub website only to find the message “Remember i2hub.”

i2hub, which enabled file swapping over a special superfast Internet2 connection among more than 200 universities, was one of several file-sharing networks to fall under recording industry pressure.

In September 2005, seven file-sharing networks including i2hub received cease-and-desist letters from the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) accusing them of enabling computer users to illegally distribute copyright-protected music online. In the notices, the trade group representing the major recording companies warned recipients of legal consequences if they continued to operate. The RIAA also brought lawsuits against 635 individuals using i2hub at 39 campuses during 2005. In a continuing effort to raise awareness against illegal file-sharing amongst students, the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) is sponsoring a student competition for a nationwide public service announcement condemning online piracy along with Students In Free Enterprise, an international nonprofit student organization devoted to creating economic opportunity. As illegal file-sharing networks are shut down, the RIAA reports that the legitimate online marketplace has already begun to expand. In addition to legal download and subscription services like Rhapsody, Napster, iTunes,, Sony Connect, Yahoo! Music and others, a promising legal peer-to-peer (P2P) network marketplace is emerging. Joining World Media, PassAlong and Intent Media in the legitimate P2P arena, iMesh has announced a legitimate P2P business model and the launch of its newly configured service. Individual record companies have also announced numerous licensing agreements in recent months with companies such as Mashboxx and Snocap., November 21, 2005, November 16, 2005 (Jon Newton)
Yale Daily News, November 16, 2005 (Ross Goldberg)
RIAA press release, November 7, 2005
See GrayZone Digest Second Quarter 2005

Artists’ Corner

John Lennon Goes Digital

He may not be alive today, but former Beatles frontman, JOHN LENNON, is still keeping up with advances in modern technology. Beginning with his recent greatest hits offering “Working Class Hero,” Lennon’s entire musical catalog will be made available for digital download. This will herald the first official release of Lennon’s material to the digital market.

Launched on December 5, 2005, shoppers can now purchase downloads of any Lennon song they can think of via a broad range of digital outlets – certain tracks are even available for mobile phones. Lennon’s entire solo catalog was made available on several online music services including Real/Rhapsody, Napster, MSN and Yahoo! Unlimited , but not on Apple’s iTunes Music Service, due to an ongoing legal battle that Apple and Beatles parent company, Apple Corps. have been waging.

The companies battled in the early 1990s when they agreed to a settlement that specified that Apple Computer would keep its trademark on computers, not music. Apple Corps. claims that Apple broke the agreement when the company launched the iTunes Music Store. Lennon’s widow, Yoko Ono, commented on the new digital releases, ‘I am very happy that John’s music is now available to a new generation of music fans,” she said. “New technology is something he always embraced and this is something he would have loved.”

Macworld, November 9, 2005 (Jim Dalrymple), November 9, 2005 (Eve Jenkin)

U.S. Busts

Be sure to peruse the Recording Industry Association of America’s (RIAA) monthly newsletter “RIAA Anti-Piracy Seizure Information,” which covers numerous bootleg, piracy and counterfeit raids across the United States.

L.A. Man Pleads Guilty to Pirating Film

On December 13, 2005, a man pleaded guilty to unlawfully posting a copy of ‘Star Wars: Episode III – Revenge of the Sith’ on the Internet the night before the film appeared in theaters.

According to the U.S. attorney’s office, Marc Hoaglin of Los Angeles, California entered his plea to one count of uploading a work being prepared for commercial distribution.

Hoaglin told the judge he obtained a prerelease copy of the “Star Wars” film from a co-worker in May 2005. The copy had been stolen a few days earlier from a post-production company hired by Lucasfilm Ltd. to put finishing touches on the film.

The illegal posting violated the Family Entertainment and Copyright Act of 2005, which made uploading a movie before its DVD release a federal felony. Hoaglin, 36, was the second person in the nation convicted under the law, and faces up to three years in prison at his sentencing on March 6, 2006.

Find Law, December 13, 2005 (Associated Press)

New York State Police Raid Local Warehouse

On November 15, 2005, the New York State Police (NYSP) announced the execution of a search warrant on a warehouse in Rochester, New York, where a man was allegedly running a pirate DVD and CD lab.

According to the NYSP, investigators seized 136 DVD and CD burners, 6,316 pirate DVDs, 7,595 pirate CDs, $16,000 in U.S. currency and five guns. The counterfeit merchandise has a retail value exceeding $100,000, according to police. In addition, a human skull was found, which the Monroe County Medical Examiner and the Rochester Police Department is continuing to investigate.

The raid was the largest pirate burning lab operation uncovered in upstate New York, resulting from a three-month-long investigation led by the NYSP, the RIAA and the MPAA.

RIAA press release, November 17, 2005

Worldwide Update

China | Italy | Japan | Russia | Spain | United Kingdom


Western Luxury Brands Victorious in Beijing Piracy Suit

Prada, Chanel and three additional luxury product companies are winners in China’s first copyright infringement case against a Beijing shopping mall owner.

According to the verdict, awarded on December 19, a landlord at the city’s Silk Street shopping mall, Beijing Xiushui Haosen Clothing Market, did nothing to stop their vendors from selling pirated goods. The court ordered the vendors and the landlord to pay $13,000 to the plaintiffs, including

According to the December 19, 2005 verdict, Beijing Xiushui Haosen Clothing Market, a landlord at the Silk Street shopping mall in Beijing, failed to stop vendors from selling goods known to have been pirated. The court ordered the landlord and vendors to pay $13,000 in compensation to the plaintiffs, which included LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton, Gucci and Burberry. According to the U.S. Commerce Department, companies around the world lose more than $60 billion annually due to Chinese piracy.

International Herald Tribune, January 4, 2006 (Bloomberg News)


Ex-Cirielli Law Cuts Down Piracy Cases

The music industry is concerned that the passing of a new Italian law will threaten music anti-piracy activity in the country. The new law, known as the Ex-Cirielli Law, could end three-quarters of all pending criminal anti-piracy trials before they have the chance to be taken to court.

The law shortens the period after which criminal cases pending trial are automatically dismissed. The change, from seven and a half to six years, will affect the majority of all pending criminal cases brought by the music industry which can take up to nine years to go to trial. Of 471 cases pending in 2004, 382 will be dismissed and similar figures are expected for 2005.

IFPI, representing the music recording industry worldwide, warns that the bill is inconsistent with international rules on enforcement of intellectual property and will put Italy out of line with other developed countries. Italy has one of the highest rates of piracy in Europe, at 25% of the total music market.

IFPI Chairman and CEO John Kennedy said: “The Ex-Cirielli law deals a huge blow to the Italian music industry and to all IP industries in the country. This law totally undermines our ability to fight piracy in a nation with one of the highest rates of piracy in the developed world.”

IFPI press release, November 11, 2005


Japan’s Downloads Grow as U.S. Market Slows

The Recording Industry Association of Japan (RIAJ) reports that 2.3 million computer downloads were bought in Japan in the third quarter of 2005 alone. This figure is more than double the sales recorded in each of the year’s previous quarters. This sharp increase has almost exclusively been attributed to the iTunes Music Store debuting in the Japanese market at the start of August 2005.

In the U.S., however, a very different picture is emerging. It is reported that – after the boom of 2004 – sales are beginning to slow down. Average weekly sales were 6.6 million in the third quarter of 2005 – up only slightly from 6.4 million in May 2005.

Round The Clock News, November 28, 2005


U.S. Senate Takes Aim at Music Piracy in Russia

The Recording Industry of America is hoping that a recent anti-piracy effort by the U.S. Senate will have an effect on illegal music downloading in Russia.

On December 21, 2005, the Senate passed a resolution stressing that the Russian Federation must provide more effective protection of intellectual property rights. If the country fails to do so, it risks being barred from the World Trade Organization and losing its eligibility to participate in the Generalized System of Preferences program.

RIAA chairman Mitch Bainwol commented, “With the passage of this resolution in the Senate, the entire U.S. Congress has made clear that the Russian government must significantly step up the fight against piracy as a condition for both its acceptance into the WTO and for receiving preferential trade benefits from the United States.”

Top Tech News, December 27, 2005 (Elizabeth Millard)


Spain’s Biggest Piracy Bust

In what is the largest operation against music and film piracy ever undertaken in Spain, police arrested 69 individuals on October 26, 2005 allegedly involved in the illegal production, storage and retail distribution of music and film discs.

Police raided nine addresses believed to be the main center of the illegal business. All of the 69 people arrested during the operation were Chinese nationals, including the three alleged to head the organization: Yi Dong Han, Zhixionh Xu and Zhubao Dong. Four have been sent to prison on judicial warrant, and many others had no legal permits to stay in Spain. A total of 23 addresses were searched in several locations in Spain including the piracy ring’s main distribution centers in Madrid and Alicante.

Large amounts of illegal material were seized by the authorities including over 60,000 recorded CD-Rs, almost 50,000 DVD-Rs and over 130,000 inlay cards, as well as over 200 CD drives and four industrial color copying machines. Thousands of Euros in cash and 21 counterfeit identity cards including four stolen passports were also found in the searches. The group was believed to have been producing over one million CD-Rs and DVD-Rs every month. The music included both local Spanish artists and well-known international titles. Some of the films had not yet been legally distributed. Spain was named as the only Western European country in IFPI’s 2005 Commercial Piracy Report’s top ten priority countries list. Piracy has devastated the country’s music industry, with sales of recorded music having fallen by 32% since 2000.

IFPI press release, October 28, 2005

United Kingdom

Counterfeit Goods Crackdown in UK

Following four consecutive raids in Operation Dawn, the UK is drawing up plans for a multi-agency approach to battling counterfeit goods traders. The December raids targeted Wembley Market in North London. Fifty to 70 people who included law enforcement marked more than 30 sellers for potential prosecution. They also seized pirated goods that would have generated £1.5 million ($2.4 million) in retail sales.

According to the UK’s Department of Trade & Industry, this comprehensive, multi-agency approach will be coordinated by the National Criminal & Intelligence Service and Patent Office.

The agencies that took part in Operation Dawn included Job Centre Plus, the Inland Revenue, the Anti-Counterfeiting Group and the British Phonographic Industry (BPI). Legal businesses and traders such as Blockbuster, approved of the raids.

Afterdawn News, January 4, 2006

Legal Beagle

Online and In-Store: The RIAA Lawsuits Continue

On behalf of its member companies, the RIAA announced a new round of copyright infringement lawsuits against 751 new individuals on December 15, 2005. The new round of lawsuits, filed as part of an ongoing effort to level the playing field for legal online music services, included students at the college campuses of Drexel University, Harvard University, and the University of Southern California.

The “John Doe” lawsuits cite individuals for illegally distributing copyrighted music on the Internet via unauthorized peer-to-peer services such as LimeWire and Kazaa, In addition to the “John Doe” litigations, the major music companies filed lawsuits against 105 named defendants, filed in Arizona, Connecticut, Georgia, Illinois, Massachusetts, Michigan, North Carolina, Nebraska, New Jersey, New York, Texas and Wisconsin.

Nearly all of the cases filed by the RIAA have been settled for a few thousand dollars and a signed pledge from the accused to get their music from legal channels. However, Patricia Santangelo, a mother of five from White Plains, New York, has recently refused the RIAA’s settlement offer, claiming that she is computer-illiterate and never took part in illegal file-sharing. The trial, set for later this year will determine if an “Internet-illiterate parent” can be held liable for her children’s downloads.

The RIAA has also taken legal action as part of a program designed to deter a continuing piracy trend: the sale of illegal music at small, established businesses. The music industry’s anti-piracy efforts are part of a larger initiative recently launched by the RIAA and the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) aimed at protecting holiday shoppers from purchasing illegal copies of CDs and DVDs and reducing the amount of illegal product readily available to the public.

On December 19, 2005, the RIAA on behalf of the major record companies also sued five New York City retailers for flagrant violations of copyright law. The lawsuits, filed in federal court, specifically asked for an injunction and legal damages, based on the amount of pirated product being offered.

In addition to the five lawsuits, the RIAA sent a new round of demand letters to the owners of 20 retail establishments in New York City and parts of California. Since this program was first launched in 2002, some 50 retail establishments have either settled out of court or had sizable penalties rendered against them. Pirated CDs can increasingly be manufactured and sold for less than legitimate releases. As a result, some retailers — such as the owners of convenience stores, small music stores, or corner markets — are attempting to make a profit by selling illegal CDs, or even manufacturing counterfeit CDs themselves. In response, the RIAA has adopted an aggressive ‘zero tolerance’ approach to retailers engaged in this activity. “The end of the year is an especially important time for the music community, and an especially fortunate time for music fans, with a great slate of new releases in stores,” said RIAA President Cary Sherman.

The RIAA estimates that the U.S. recording industry loses more than $300 million annually to physical goods piracy., December 30, 2005
RIAA press release, December 19, 2005
RIAA press release, December 15, 2005

IFPI Launches Global Action Against Illegal File Sharing

The largest escalation in the campaign against illegal online file sharing was just announced by the recording industry. On November 15, 2005, it was unveiled that 2,100 new cases were being brought against illegal file sharers in five new European countries, Asia — and for the first time ever, South America.

Copyright infringers in Argentina, Switzerland, Sweden, Singapore and Hong Kong risk criminal penalties and fines for damages in a global anti-piracy campaign in which thousands of individuals — mostly young men aged 20 to 30 — have paid out at least $3,000 for illegally uploading copyrighted music on P2P (peer-to-peer) networks. This latest round of cases brings the total number of litigations against file uploaders to more than 3,800 in 16 countries. This fourth wave of cases since the inception of this global campaign in March targets users of the largest unauthorized networks. This includes eDonkey, Gnutella (BearShare), DirectConnect, FastTrack (Kazaa), SoulSeek, WinMX and BitTorrent.

Recent actions in the previously mentioned countries join the U.S., UK, Germany, France, Finland, Austria, Denmark, Italy, Iceland, Ireland, the Netherlands and Japan. This brings the number of countries currently in litigation to 17.

In Argentina’s first actions against file sharers, four of 10 internet users use illegal P2P services. Those who swap files are high-income earners, generally aged 20 to 30. Singapore has had 33 criminal complaints filed by the recording industry that implicate Gnutella and FastTrack users, which followed after the industry initiated its “Don’t let the music die” campaign, which focused on education in hundreds of schools.

In Hong Kong, 22 big uploaders face civil actions. In November, a person who uploaded three movies to BitTorrent received three months in prison. In Sweden, music industry representatives filed 15 criminal complaints against uploaders. More complaints will follow. At least a million individuals file share illegally. One of nine Swedes has illegally shared files. In October, a person uploaded a Swedish movie and was convicted of infringement and ordered to pay a fine.

Regarding the enforcement escalation against the sharing of copyrighted music and the newly established criminal and financial penalties in Latin America and Southeast Asia, IFPI Chairman and CEO John Kennedy stated, “This reflects the sharply rising levels of Internet piracy in those regions. The message today is that, from Sweden to Hong Kong and from Singapore to Argentina, there are no havens for the theft of music on the Internet.”

IFPI press release, November 15, 2005

Grokster P2P Agrees to Shut Down

Peer-to-peer network Grokster Ltd. has agreed to shut down their website and pay out $50 million in a piracy settlement. The company lost a Supreme Court case over their filesharing software which has been a popular online tool for users stealing films and music. This was after complaints by the music industry and Hollywood and comes four months following the court’s June 2005 ruling in MGM vs. Grokster. This decision by Groster’s owners and operators settles the three-year-old case with U.S. music publishers, major labels and motion picture studios.

The sudden November 7 settlement bans the network from participating in copyright file theft and requires them to stop giving away their filesharing software. As part of the deal, they must also stop distributing their client application and cease operations of their system and software. The website now states that its filesharing service is illegal and no longer available. It goes on to explain that there are legal services where users can download movies and music.

Grokster executives plan to create a legal and fee-based “Grokster 3G” service before the end of the year. It will be rolled out under a new parent company. P2P network Mashboxx, which is partly owned by former Grokster president Wayne Rosso, has inked a licensing deal with Sony BMG Music Entertainment.

RIAA head Mitch Bainwol describes the agreement as “a chapter that ends on a high note for the recording industry, the tech community and music fans and consumers everywhere.”

RIAA press release, November 7, 2005
Yahoo! News, November 7, 2005 (Ted Bridis)
See GrayZone Digest Third Quarter 2005

********** SIDEBAR **********

Automatic Wireless MP3 Sharing: A Nightmare for the RIAA

In Gothenburg, Sweden at The Viktoria Institute, engineers are working on an idea that is putting fear in the heart of the music industry. Called Push Music, this software automatically shares music files with users who are nearby that have similar preferences.

This advanced technology monitors the user’s listening history and “learns” what kind of new music they may enjoy. This concept would use Wi-Fi (wireless) music players to establish an automatic P2P (peer-to-peer) connection which lets users browse others’ music collections and grab a copy of anything that they like.

The technology poses an enormous threat to the music industry, which is waging war against unauthorized filesharing. Anytime/anywhere wireless auto transfers of songs will present the RIAA with a formidable challenge in their mission to protect artists’ intellectual property and stop widespread music theft.

The Raw Feed, January 5, 2005 (Mike Elgan)


Quick Bits and Bytes

Companies Plagued by Counterfeit Drugs

Pfizer Inc., in a move to thwart counterfeit Viagra, has included special radio frequency identification tags on all packages of its anti-impotence pill to verify they are the authentic Pfizer product. The world’s largest drugmaker said the costly new technology would create barriers “for criminals who might attempt to counterfeit our products.”

The tiny tags are small computer chips that have been affixed to the underside of labels on each bottle of Viagra, as well as on cases and pallets of the drug. The invisible tags relay an electronic code that verifies the product is real and authorized Viagra. Pharmacists and wholesalers can then use specially designed electronic scanners that communicate the code over the Internet to a secure Pfizer website for verification purposes. Roche, the Swiss pharmaceutical manufacturer of Tamiflu, has also been affected by the counterfeit drug market. Customs agents have recently intercepted more than 50 counterfeit shipments of the antiviral drug that is being stockpiled in anticipation of a bird flu pandemic, marking the first such seizures in the U.S. The first package was intercepted on November 26, 2005 at an air mail facility near the San Francisco International Airport. Since then, agents have seized 51 separate packages, each containing up to 50 counterfeit capsules labeled generic Tamiflu. According to the Food and Drug Administration Office of Enforcement, the fake drugs had none of Tamiflu’s active ingredients and initial tests indicated there was some vitamin C in the capsules.

CNN January 6, 2006 (Reuters)
ABC News, December 19, 2005 (Brian Skoloff)

Microsoft Continues War on Counterfeit Software

As part of an ongoing campaign against piracy, Microsoft along with the Business Software Alliance (BSA) successfully shut down a Manchester-based Internet retailer, Zoobon, for selling counterfeit Microsoft software.

According to Microsoft, it had received a number of complaints from Zoobon customers unhappy with the quality of the products they had been sold. In an investigation conducted over the course of a year with the help of eBay, Zoobon was found to have counterfeited nearly $5 million worth of software, according to Microsoft. Following the investigations, an out-of-court settlement was reached between Microsoft and the individuals behind Zoobon under which they ceased trading and agreed not to sell counterfeit Microsoft software in the future. Zoobon’s site on eBay has been closed down as well. The BSA has indicated that it prefers not to file lawsuits but rather presses companies to reach a settlement after determining there were violations. According to the BSA, most investigations begin with a call to its hotline or with a report made through its website by a current or former employee of a suspected company. BSA attorneys then contact the organizations, which usually cooperate and conduct audits.

The BSA has also started a rewards program to intensify its fight against software piracy in the United States. In December 2005, the BSA began offering rewards of up to $50,000 for qualifying piracy reports., December 8, 2005
ZDNet UK, December 8, 2005 (Colin Barker)

Scroll to Top