Napster – The Battle Continues
Napster must cease distributing copyrighted material, says U.S. District Judge Marilyn Hall Patel. In the ruling, the music-swapping website was given until Friday, July 28 by midnight, PT, to comply with the ruling. Faced with the possibility of being shut down, Napster filed a last-minute appeal with the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. Just hours prior to the deadline, the court issued a stay on the injunction.
The below link provides a complete transcript of Patel’s decision, issued orally, in which she explains the basis for granting the injunction. Because it marks one of the first times a judge has issued a decision in a case of online music-swapping, Patel’s interpretation of the law is likely to be widely cited in subsequent cases and will be crucial to the Court of Appeals as it grapples with the case.
– CNet Tech, January 2, 2002 (republished)
Other Interesting Napster Reading:
Survey: 13 Million Americans Have Downloaded Music for Free; CNN.com, June 9, 2000
RIAA Asks Judge to Pull All Major-Label Songs Off – Napster CNET News.com, June 12, 2000 (John Borland)
Foes Hone Strategy for Web Copyright Clash
– New York Times, June 16, 2000 (Matt Richtel)
Napster Goes to Washington – Wired News, July 11, 2000 (Brad King)
Judge Orders Injunction Vs. Napster; Associated Press, July 26, 2000
Napster Shutdown Seen as Potential Boon for Competitors – CNN.com, July 27, 2000
Napster Asks Court to Block Order Shutting Down Online Music Service – CNN.com, July 27, 2000
Appeals Court Grnts Napster Reprieve – CNN.com, July 28, 2000
Napster Wins Stay in Federal Appeals Court; Associated Press, July 28, 2000
Napster Legal Scrap Could Backfire on Record Industry – Reuters, July 29, 2000
Project Code Name: Lapster! – MP3.com Press Release, August 3, 2000
Napster, DVD Cases Raise Copyright Questions in Digital Age
– CNN.com, August 7, 2000 (Raju Chebium)
Where Napster Has Gone, Others Will Follow; Los Angeles Times.com, August 21, 2000 (Jeremy Rifkin)
Napster Files Brief in Defense: Yahoo! News, August 23, 2000 (Andrew Dansby)
Why Scour is Not the New Napster, Salon, August 22, 2000 (Damien Cave)
(Dan Rodrigues defends his multimedia search engine, even as it faces a nasty lawsuit.)
Where is online music headed? Our roundtable of performers, executives, and revolutionaries hashes it out. (Yahoo! Internet Life/ZDNet Music)
Artists Against Piracy website: ArtistsAgainstPiracy.com/
– created to give artists a voice in determining how their music is presented, marketed, and distributed on the Internet.
The Next Piracy Panic: Software
Microsoft’s Bill Gates is watching a case that’s currently in court–and surprisingly, it’s not his own. If filesharing site Napster succeeds in appealing the court order that would shut it down, and the court fules that it’s legal to swap music online, is that a go-ahead for users to share other digital property–such as, perhaps, Windows?
The Next Piracy Panic: Software
– CNN.com, August 21, 2000 (Mike Romano)
MP3.COM Settles with Majors
The copyright infringement suit brought by Warner Music Group, BMG, EMI, Sony and Universal, following the launch of the My.MP3.com system late last year has been settled with four of the five record companies. The terms of the settlements with Warner, BMG, EMI and Sony are believed to be around $20 million per label and each of these majors has also agreed to license its catalog to MP3.com on a nonexclusive basis. However, U.S. District Judge Jed S. Rakoff ruled that for purposes of determining damages, the copyright works in the case are the CDs that MP3.com has made available for Internet users to download, not the individual songs contained on those CDs, leaving the company liable for a smaller amount of damages.
MP3.com has agreed to pay 1.5 cents for every stored song and .3 cents for every song streamed by an MP3.com user. MP3.com is also facing a suit from the indie sector filed by Tee Vee Toons (TVT) Records on May 24.
MP3.com Settles Copyright Infringement Suit with Warner Music Group – MP3.com Press Release, June 9, 2000
MP3.com and Sony Settle Copyright Dispute – E-Commerce Times, August 22, 2000 (Gary Gately)
Judge’s Ruling Would Limit Damages for MP3.com; Bloomberg News, August 24, 2000
“If a Song Means a Lot to You, Imagine What it Means to Us”
– Musicians Unite for Copyrights
In an effort to educate consumers, an industry-backed artist coalition, Artists Against Piracy, placed full-page ads on July 11 in the New York Times, Los Angeles Times, USA Today, Wall Street Journal and the Washington Post. The first ad was intended to support Metallica band member Lars Urlich’s testimony in the Napster case. Subsequent Artists Against Piracy messages in the near future will aim at educating the public about music on the Internet. Everclear’s Art Alexakis, Alanis Morisette and Christina Aquilera are among the nearly 70 musicians who have joined the coalition.
Wired News, July 12, 2000 (Brad King)
Alexakis, Alanis Among Artists Against Piracy – RollingStone.com, July 14, 2000
Beat the Boots Award Winners: Pearl Jam Announces Official Bootlegs
In a June 4 statement on their Sony Music website, Pearl Jam announced plans to release officially sanctioned double-disc live recordings for each of the 28 shows on their recent European tour. This decision is the latest proactive step taken by the group to deter sales of expensive bootlegs. Most unauthorized live CDs cost $25, which would make recordings of each Pearl Jam set $50 given the length of their shows. The Pearl Jam offering includes at least 56 CDs. Brett Eliason, Pearl Jam sound man, who mixed and engineered the group’s “Live on Two Legs” album, mixed down the concert recordings after the Euro leg of the tour wrapped on July 3. The live CDs can be purchased starting September 5 at the following websites: http://www.tenclub.net and http://www.pearljam.com. The band in on a U.S. tour through November 5.
Wall of Sound, June 6, 2000
Worldwide Piracy Update
According to IFPI’s Music Piracy Report 2000, there is growing evidence of the link between CD piracy and organized crime which could be responsible for up to 75% of the illegal trade. In 1999 a new trend of “underground” pirate CD plants emerged with illicit plants discovered in Latin America, Asia and Europe. Encouraging moves have been made by governments in Hong Kong, Mexico, Italy and the Ukraine with the implementation of strong new laws and progress has been made by the European Commission towards creating a pan-EU anti-piracy strategy. The increase in the sales of CD-Rs has had an insidious effect on the music business in Europe, particularly the singles-driven dance industry. Internet piracy is on the rise with at least 25 million infringing files available on file-trading services such as Napster and MP3.com and an estimated download rate of 1 billion annually. A major move to improve the secure delivery of music is the Secure Digital Music Initiative (SDMI) which involves computer manufacturers and the information technologies community. There is speculation that MP3.com may soon sign up with the SDMI following its settlement with major labels. IFPI’s Main Board granted new resources to the global enforcement team, whose headcount will be doubled to 50 by the end of this year.
Music Piracy Tops 500 Million Discs, Proliferates on the Internet – IFPI Press Release, June 14, 2000
Pirate CD Sales Considered Billion-Dollar Business – CBC Infoculture, June 14, 2000
The record industry applauded the announcement June 5 of an action plan agreed on between President Clinton and President Leonid Kuchma of the Ukraine to tackle head-on the CD piracy problem in that country. In order to avoid possible US trade sanctions, the plan is due to be fully implemented by November 1, 2000. The Ukraine government has taken immediate steps, suspending production at five CD plants known to produce pirate discs. The government is also committed to enforcement and legislative initiatives. Currently, the Ukraine is one of the predominant producers of pirate optical discs in the world, with a capacity to produce 70 million discs annually, nearly all for export.
Record Industry Hails Ukraine Anti-Piracy Measures – IFPI Press Release, June 6, 2000
Ukraine Closes Down Counterfeit CD Plants – CBC Infoculture, June 7, 2000
On June 23, major record labels including BMG, Sony and Warner Bros., filed a copyright infringement suit against MP3Board Inc. claiming the site posts links to thousands of “pirate” copies of the plaintiff’s copyright-protected sound recordings which can be downloaded by users directly onto their computers free of charge. MP3Board’s site provides indexing, searching and linking of music-related sites and files over the Internet. This follows the filing of a suit by MP3Board on June 5 to prevent the Recording Industry of America (RIAA) from shutting down its website. On July 18, MP3Board filed a further claim against the RIAA asking for redress for the RIAA’s role in temporarily shutting down their website. They contend that they simply post links to other websites and that there is nothing illegal about such hyperlinks while the RIAA alleges that MP3Board.com actively solicits users to post illegal sites. MP3Board’s latest strategy was unveiled on August 22 when they filed an addition to their lawsuit asking that a judge declare its searches of the Gnutella file-sharing network to be legal, further stating that if those searches aren’t legal, then AOL, which employed the programmers who created Gnutella, should share the liability.
Warned by the Music Industry, Web Site Files Suit; New York Times, June 6, 2000 (Matt Richtel)
Major Recording Labels Sues MP3Board on Copyright; Reuters, June 23, 2000
MP3Board Countersues RIAA – CNet News.Com, July 18, 2000 (John Borland)
CNet News, August 22, 2000
Internet Copyright Laws Debated
Content providers and the federal copyright office are arguing that Internet companies should be denied the blanket broadcast licenses which currently allow cable operators and satellite companies to retransmit broadcast programming without getting individual consent from each company. With these licenses comes a requirement to pay a portion of their revenues into a fund which is distributed to the individual copyright holders. Content providers are against granting Internet companies licenses in part because of the potential for near-perfect digital copies to be made. At this time Internet businesses must get permission from each copyright holder individually in order to stream broadcast programming or other content.
Associated Press, June 15, 2000
Hollywood Cracks Down on Web VCR Site
RecordTV, a website that acts as a VCR, recording TV shows for later playback, is being sued by the motion picture industry and a dozen TV and movie studios for violation of their copyrights. This lawsuit is the latest in the film industry’s efforts to stop online businesses that take distribution of TV or movies out of studios’ or broadcasters’ hands. Canadian company iCraveTV.com was closed down earlier this year in a similar case.
CNetNews.com, June 15, 2000 (John Borland)
New York Court Case Pits Hollywood vs. Hackers
On August 17, U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan handed the film industry a victory against digital video piracy. The plaintiffs in the case, which included Hollywood’s eight biggest movie studios, sought to bar journalist Eric Corley from republishing the software code that unlocks the media scrambling within DVDs. Corley, publisher of 2600 (http://www.2600.org) a computer hacker magazine and web site, has been permanently blocked in making available online or posting links to DeCSS software code. The judge found that “…in an era in which the transmission of computer viruses … can disable systems upon which the nation depends and in which other computer code also is capable of inflicting harm, society must be able to regulate the use and dissemination of code in appropriate circumstance.”
Reuters, July 16, 2000
Point Your Browser Tip:
Attorneys in Video Hacker Court Case Predict Mass Piracy
CNN.com, July 18, 2000
DeCSS Piracy Case Looms – Reuters/Wired News, August 8, 2000
Judge Orders Injunction in DVD Hacker Case; Reuters, August 17, 2000
Quick Bits and Bytes
Web Pirates Unearth Treasure: Hit Films
Young People are terrifying Hollywood. When they want to see a movie, they don’t need to go to the multiplex or to their local video rental … they can go to their computer.
Washington Post, June 7, 2000 (Paul Farhi)
American Groups Unite to Fight Piracy
The Motion Picture Association and IFPI signed a deal June 5 to form the Anti-Piracy Certification/Compliance Program. The program will battle music, audiovisual and Internet piracy.
CBC Infoculture, June 6, 2000
IFPI, MPA Join Forces To Fight Global Piracy
Bootleggers Use Hearing Aid To Record
Bootleggers are taking advantage of a federal law requiring arenas to offer patrons use of an assistive listening device (ALD) to obtain high-quality feeds of live shows via a low-level FM frequency broadcast. The pirates then steal the headset feed, giving them near-pristine versions of concerts.
Associated Press, July 31, 2000